Comments on How to track your Linux laptop

Color me unbelieving.

Riddle me this:

A laptop is stolen, reformatted and loaded with a new OS.

How will it ever be found?

Of course, if your system is reformatted there will be no way to locate it. However, you can set your BIOS settings in such a way, that a thief would find it much more difficult to install a new system. Even a few logins in your system could yield enough information to help you locate it. :)

This is a horrible idea.  The laptop is nothing compared to your personal data.  In what world is the better solution to let a thief access your personal info while prey sends you snapshots in the hope some police department will even care to help you. Encrypt and backup your data and forget the laptop, it's replaceable.  But if you must setup your main os on a hidden volume and allow it to boot into a decoy os that uses prey.  But that is so much effort for nothing. 

Well, there is no good or horrible idea really. It all depends on what you want to do, and I am not expressing any opinions here, I am just showing how things are done for those who want to do them. My own data for example are worth much less than my systems. Actually, I rarely even have any personal data stored inside my computers. How does that sound to you? 

These are terrible solutions.   The price of a laptop is nothing comparing to the value of the data contained within the laptop.  

ALWAYS encrypt your portable devices and backup your stuff. 

No police department will ever help you track down a $200 laptop. 

How can you suppose that? I may own a laptop that costs +$2500 and contains almost no personal data at all. If the post doesn't concern you, it doesn't mean that the solution is "terrible". Those tools exist for those who need them, and there are people who do actually need them. I will write another article on how to encrypt your data as this is a different case altogether. Thanks :)

So my laptop is LUKS encrypted, if it gets stolen, there is no practical way somebody can manage to boot Linux without reformatting the disk.

@Bill Toulas.  For some reason I couldn't reply under your reply.  You are correct and horrible was a bit harsh. I think this article would have been a little better with some disclaimers on what you can possibly do with this info if it starts phoning home. 

First off is to file a police report.  Otherwise the police will not give you the time of day, they still may not after you do and all you have left is vigilante justice, staking out libraries and such.  If the thief has any clue at all they will securely wipe the drive before they do anything, or will not connect to the Net at all while they rummage through your stuff.

I did test Prey some months ago, but it was the local version that used email to notify you, not the web version.  I stand by my assessment though in that the average user does have personal info on their laptop. (banking info, pictures, taxes, bills, social security number in some document etc etc etc).   I am interested in using this software on a decoy OS with my actual OS on a hidden encrypted partition and will one day test that....ya right who am I kidding.  I think that would be an acceptable approach. 

I guess my critisism is related to the fact that the average user would read this and think this is a good security solution for them, when in fact it is more akin to closing the barn door after the horse left.  Google and you will find some people who have used this software and indeed had screenshots sent to them of strangers surfing their Facebook pages and looking at their pictures.  That's crazy, encryption is the number one thing people should do on laptops.

Anyway, your review of the actual software was spot on.  Just the context I take issue with.

Cheers.

Thank you.

This is a great article.

People commenting negatively, until it happens to them.

This is not just about your laptop, or your data.

Its about locating the criminal. And your other belongings.

Wake up. Don't make the crooks sound smarter than you.

I'm in the process of helping someone whose Win PC was taken along with many home valuables.

They still have their older laptop, so I'm going to put LM and then one of these solutions so we can track them like an Android device in the future if this happens again, as they came back 3x in succession to the home to steal more valuables. Daring!

Police are not helpful.

the best way would be to put an hidden gps tracking device in your computer, most of laptops have unused space where you can put things and desktop have alot of space for that and you will even be able to get it back after they formated the disk and reinstalled the windows.

someone stole my laptop ................