Important feature requests (security)

Discussion in 'Feature Requests' started by Jemt, Jan 21, 2012.

  1. Jemt

    Jemt New Member

    Hello developers.

    First, allow me to thank you for an awesome product with great potential. I managed to configure a brand new server and get a pretty good insight into how ISPConfig works in about 6-7 hours. I like how simple it is, yet packed with lots of great features.

    Now, to my feature requests.

    1) As far as I understand, [Fast-]CGI is the recommended way of integrating PHP, as scripts are executed with user privileges - but only as long as SuEXEC is enabled (right?). Unfortunately a client may choose not to enable SuEXEC, leaving [FAST-]CGI just as "open" as mod_php (forcing me to use PHP SAFE Mode). I would very much like to be able to force the use of SuEXEC. Either within ISPConfig, or using a configuration file (is that possible?).

    2) I don't want my clients being able to enable CGI, Ruby, Python, SSL etc. for their websites, but there seems to be no options to disable these features. Again, I feel the client has too much to say in this matter.

    3) I'm able to set quota for websites and e-mail accounts, but not for FTP accounts - again, the client can enter a MB value to his or her liking. Could you have it respect the quota for websites?

    4) I wasn't able to remove a SSL certificate created for one of my websites. I chose "Delete certificate" from the drop down and Saved the website, but the certificate was not removed. I had to remove the entire website.

    5) Why is it possible to edit ordinary client accounts under System > Edit user, when such behaviour may damage data? It should be possible to only display admin accounts (if those are safe to edit).

    I hope this does not sound like a lot of complaining. I'm nearly trying to help you guys improve the product. On the other hand there's a chance my problems can be solved using alternative measures (in that case, please enlighten me).

    Again, thank you very much for the great work that has been put into ISPConfig and the huge manual.

    Best regards
    Jimmy Thomsen
  2. Jemt

    Jemt New Member

    Hello again.

    I have now been working with ISPConfig for a couple of days now, and I've realized that I'm probabaly wrong regarding bullet 1).

    SAFE Mode does not seem to be necessary (or appropriate), as open_basedir and Suhosin takes care of most security related problems. Please correct me if I am wrong. However, I still don't think the client should be able to determine whether to use SuEXEC or not.

  3. till

    till Super Moderator

    1) Safemode is deprecated and will be removed in new PHP versions.It has been replaced by more granular security functions like open_basedir, disable_functions etc. Please see PHP manualfor details. Beside that, see 2).

    2) If you create a website as administrator for the client, then the client can not alter these settings.

    3) The FTP quota is always as "sub" quota of the website quota, so even if you set it to -1 the client can not upload more data then you set in the web quota.

    4) I will check that, but deleting the cert here with ISPConfig works for me.

    5) These settings are required and useful for advanced users. If you are more familar with ISPConfig and know more about the underlaying permission system, you will see that.
    Last edited: Jan 23, 2012

Share This Page