550-The recipient cannot be verified email problem

[safoo]

Seems to be a simple problem, but I can not figure this one out:

I have a Ubuntu server setup using the perfect setup for 6.06 and with Ispconfig. This server's hostname is server.anaselectronics.com.

anaselectronics.com is on the main IP of the system. On a 2nd IP, I have asuslaptops.net. Both of these sites are setup through Ispconfig. I can send and receive emails to both domains successfully from:
- from email address of one domain to the other domain
- from php scripts on the server using the php mail() function
- from my gmail account

The problem I have occurs when sending email from a different server housed at a different datacenter. The hostname is server.nyxmotorsports.com and the domain being used for sending the email is case-mod.com.

When sending email from something@case-mod.com to anything@anaselectronics.com, the emails go through just fine.

When sending email from something@case-mod.com to anything@asuslaptops.net, I get the following errors:

If sending from thunderbird, it says

An error occurred while sending mail. The mail server responded: "The recipient cannot be verified. Please check all recipients of this message to verify they are valid." Please verify that your email address is correct in your Mail preferences and try again.

If sending mail from telnet mail.case-mod.com 25, it accepts RCPT TO: <anything@anaselectronics.com>, but RCPT TO:<anything@asuslaptops.net> returns

550-"The recipient cannot be verified. Please check all recipients of this
550 message to verify they are valid."

If sending from the php mail() function using a php script on case-mod.com server, emails sent to anything@anaselectronics.com go through. Any emails sent to anything@asuslaptops.net do not come through and bounce back after few hours:

A message that you sent could not be delivered to one or more of its recipients. This is a permanent error. The following address(es) failed:

anything@asuslaptops.net
Unrouteable address

So basically, it seems the site setup on the main IP of the server can receive emails without any problems. The problem I am having here seems to occur on a domain that is setup on a secondary IP in Ispconfig.

Thanks in advance for any help.

[safoo]

var/log/mail.log shows the following just after trying to send an email to anything@asuslaptops.net from thunderbird:

Nov 26 22:47:42 server postfix/qmgr[697]: 736C53127D7: from=<root@www.case-mod.com>, size=790, nrcpt=1 (queue active)
Nov 26 22:47:42 server postfix/qmgr[697]: 0A1883127CE: from=<root@www.case-mod.com>, size=790, nrcpt=1 (queue active)
Nov 26 22:47:42 server postfix/qmgr[697]: 055763127D6: from=<root@www.case-mod.com>, size=790, nrcpt=1 (queue active)
Nov 26 22:47:42 server postfix/qmgr[697]: E10353127DA: from=<root@www.case-mod.com>, size=790, nrcpt=1 (queue active)
Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[717]: certificate verification failed for www.case-mod.com: num=18:self signed certificate
Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[717]: certificate peer name verification failed for www.case-mod.com: CommonName mis-match: aet.rackshack.net
Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[705]: certificate verification failed for www.case-mod.com: num=18:self signed certificate
Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[713]: certificate verification failed for www.case-mod.com: num=18:self signed certificate
Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[705]: certificate peer name verification failed for www.case-mod.com: CommonName mis-match: aet.rackshack.net
Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[713]: certificate peer name verification failed for www.case-mod.com: CommonName mis-match: aet.rackshack.net
Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[721]: certificate verification failed for www.case-mod.com: num=18:self signed certificate
Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[721]: certificate peer name verification failed for www.case-mod.com: CommonName mis-match: aet.rackshack.net
Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[713]: certificate verification failed for www.case-mod.com: num=18:self signed certificate
Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[705]: certificate peer name verification failed for www.case-mod.com: CommonName mis-match: aet.rackshack.net
Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[713]: certificate peer name verification failed for www.case-mod.com: CommonName mis-match: aet.rackshack.net
Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[721]: certificate verification failed for www.case-mod.com: num=18:self signed certificate
Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[721]: certificate peer name verification failed for www.case-mod.com: CommonName mis-match: aet.rackshack.net
Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[717]: Server certificate could not be verified
Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[705]: Server certificate could not be verified
Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[713]: Server certificate could not be verified
Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[721]: Server certificate could not be verified
Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[717]: 055763127D6: to=<root@www.case-mod.com>, orig_to=<root>, relay=www.case-mod.com[216.40.245.93], delay=318162, status=deferred (host www.case-mod.com[216.40.245.93] said: 451 Temporary local problem - please try later (in reply to RCPT TO command))Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[705]: 736C53127D7: to=<root@www.case-mod.com>, orig_to=<root>, relay=www.case-mod.com[216.40.245.93], delay=231761, status=deferred (host www.case-mod.com[216.40.245.93] said: 451 Temporary local problem - please try later (in reply to RCPT TO command))Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[721]: E10353127DA: to=<root@www.case-mod.com>, orig_to=<root>, relay=www.case-mod.com[216.40.245.93], delay=404562, status=deferred (host www.case-mod.com[216.40.245.93] said: 451 Temporary local problem - please try later (in reply to RCPT TO command))Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[713]: 0A1883127CE: to=<root@www.case-mod.com>, orig_to=<root>, relay=www.case-mod.com[216.40.245.93], delay=145362, status=deferred (host www.case-mod.com[216.40.245.93] said: 451 Temporary local problem - please try later (in reply to RCPT TO command))

Another question: currently the MX records for asuslaptops.net points to it's IP address. Should these point to anaselectronics.com instead?

What should be in /etc/mailname...I currently have "www.anaselectronics.com"

[safoo]

Do you I need to list additional IP's in /etc/hosts. Currently I have:

127.0.0.1       localhost.localdomain localhost
8.14.145.114    server.anaselectronics.com server

Do I need to add 8.14.145.115 asuslaptops.net asuslaptops?

[till]

Is asuslaptops.net registered in DNS and does it have a A-Record that points to your server IP address?

Another question: currently the MX records for asuslaptops.net points to it's IP address. Should these point to anaselectronics.com instead?

Yes.

[safoo]

Originally Posted by till

Is asuslaptops.net registered in DNS and does it have a A-Record that points to your server IP address?

The main IP of the server is 8.14.146.114. I have a 2nd IP of 8.14.146.115.

In Ispconfig, anaselectronics.com has IP set to 8.14.145.114 and asuslaptops.net is set to 8.14.146.115

In DNS, which is set through my registrar, the A and MX records for asuslaptops.net both point to 8.14.146.115.

So you are saying that the A record should point to 8.14.146.115 and the MX record point to 8.14.146.114?

[safoo]

Ok...I have changed the MX record for asuslaptops.net. It doesn't solve my problem of the emails being rejected when emailed from case-mod.com.

As i mentioned, sending from gmail works just right. What I think it happening is that my postfix is rejecting email from case-mod.com perhaps due to some setting it doesn't like for email received from case-mod.com . Any way to find out why this is happening?

[till]

Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[717]: 055763127D6: to=<root@www.case-mod.com>, orig_to=<root>, relay=www.case-mod.com[216.40.245.93], delay=318162, status=deferred (host www.case-mod.com[216.40.245.93] said: 451 Temporary local problem - please try later (in reply to RCPT TO command))Nov 26 22:47:45 server postfix/smtp[705]: 736C53127D7: to=<root@www.case-mod.com>, orig_to=<root>, relay=www.case-mod.com[216.40.245.93], delay=231761, status=deferred (host www.case-mod.com[216.40.245.93] said: 451 Temporary local problem - please try later (in reply to RCPT TO command))

The configuration problem for this error is on case-mod.com. Is case-mod.com hosted on your server?

[safoo]

Thanks for the direction, Till.

After more reading, I saw some mention of /etc/localdomains file. It seems on case-mod.com server, it showed asuslaptops.net as a localdomain. Deleting that entry from cpanel seems to have fixed the issue.

You were correct that it was a problem on that server.