Routing multiple FTP servers

[koroshiya1]

Hi there (never mind the grammar in this post)

I have got this problem with my second ftp server.

My first ftp serv works fine, I forwarded port 21 on my router (NAT) to my first server and it works

Now my second ftp server cannot use port 21 right?
so I configured it at port 79 and did a forwarding on my router to my second ftp server on port 79

I also made a port range forwarding to my second ftp server (for passive connections)

192.168.1.54 (first FTP)
192.168.1.60 (second FTP)

**nat table snippet**
21 -> 21 192.168.1.54
79 -> 79 192.168.1.60
40000:40100 192.168.1.60
**nat table snippet**

I configured the ftp server with 2 deamons (I never run them at the same time)

vsftpd (very secure ftp deamon)
pure-ftpd (pure..)

On intranet 192.168.1.x clients can login to both servers
doesn't matter witch deamon I run

I configured vsftd like this:
**************************************
anonymous_enable=YES
local_enable=YES
write_enable=YES
local_umask=022
dirmessage_enable=YES
xferlog_enable=YES
connect_from_port_20=NO
xferlog_std_format=YES
ftpd_banner=Welcome to FTP server 2
pasv_enable=YES
pasv_promiscuous=YES
pasv_min_port=40000
pasv_max_port=40100
pasv_address=192.168.1.60
pam_service_name=vsftpd
userlist_enable=YES
listen=YES
listen_port=79
tcp_wrappers=YES
*******************************************


And pure-ftp like this:
*******************************************

ChrootEveryone yes

BrokenClientsCompatibility no
MaxClientsNumber 50
Daemonize yes
MaxClientsPerIP 8
VerboseLog no
DisplayDotFiles yes
AnonymousOnly no
NoAnonymous no
SyslogFacility ftp
DontResolve yes
MaxIdleTime 15
LimitRecursion 2000 8
AnonymousCanCreateDirs no
MaxLoad 4

DefaultAddress 192.168.1.60
PassivePortRange 40000 40100
ForcePassiveIP (ip from ISP)

AntiWarez yes
Bind 192.168.1.60,79

Umask 133:022
MinUID 100
AllowUserFXP yes
AllowAnonymousFXP no
ProhibitDotFilesWrite no
ProhibitDotFilesRead no
AutoRename no
AnonymousCantUpload no
MaxDiskUsage 99
CustomerProof yes
*******************************************

Now the problem is
I can't contact my second ftp server from the outside (internet)

[falko]

Did you tell your FTP clients to use port 79? Did you try both active and passive transfers in your FTP clients?

[koroshiya1]

yes i did, I tested from my house and made a php script to test it remote from "outside" while i'm at work (working on intranet). Tested the script and manual login on my other FTP serv and it works

[falko]

Do your firewalls (on the router and your server) allow connections to port 79?

[koroshiya1]

Yes they do...

[falko]

What's the output of

netstat -tap

and

iptables -L

on the server where you run FTP on port 79?