Originally Posted by till
1) Point all your domains in DNS to your external IP address.
2) Forward the ports you named above to your internal server IP address.
3) Setup the websites in ISPCOnfig with your internal server IP, it must be the same IP where you forwarded the ports on your router.
Thanks for the quick response Till. I had tried that set-up, and just tried it again. Unfortunately, as soon as I add a second site, I get the shared IP error.
Are there settings from my DNS provider (yahoo.com, both domains are set up as masked forwarding) that would effect this? Or router issues I could look into?